Big Blue Review: Week 10 vs. Commanders; L; WAS: 24, NYG: 21

On Thursday night, the Giants could have positioned themselves to win the NFC East by Thanksgiving and celebrate their first playoff appearance since 2023. They could have squashed the Washington Commanders in front of a raucous home crowd.

Instead, for the first time in John Harbaugh’s tenure, the Giants shot themselves in the foot. Fourth-quarter disasters were supposed to be history. Instead, despite two fourth-quarter interceptions, the Giants lost after leading with less than two minutes left.

Even after surrendering the lead, the Giants had three timeouts and 48 seconds to kick a game-tying field goal. Instead, with 34 seconds left, JJ McCarthy fired a deep shot down the right sideline to Malik Nabers, but he didn’t pivot, and McCarthy got picked.

It was the worst of a series of poor play calls that cost the Giants and delayed their division title.

Nabers is talented enough to become a top-five NFL wide receiver. If not for his season-ending ACL tear last year, which probably hasn’t fully healed yet, or Jaxson Dart’s season-ending knee injury, he’d probably already have top-five status.

So Nabers has the right to keep asking for the football, but when his quarterback and coaches trust him in a game-changing moment, he has to step up. As unnecessary as the play call was, Nabers had time and space to adjust his route.

The Giants’ kicking woes are another reason offensive coordinator Matt Nagy tried to win it all on that final drive. Dominic Zvada, who is 4-for-9 on field goals in his last three games, botched a 33-yard chip shot with 4:04 left in the first quarter. It was the Giants’ only field goal attempt of the game.

While Zvada’s first-quarter miss didn’t directly cost the Giants the game, his inconsistency might have limited his later usage. Actions speak louder than words, and while Harbaugh continues to defend his rookie kicker, he didn’t show it on Thursday night.

“You can’t start firing people left and right as soon as a guy doesn’t make a play, especially kickers or rookies,” said Harbaugh, whose biggest strength is special teams. “I’m not going to panic halfway through the season with a guy who’s made a bunch of kicks. […] He’s going to make kicks, and he’s going to make a lot of kicks. I believe in him.”

Sure, Zvada will make a lot of kicks, but the Giants can’t depend on him right now. The Giants have been searching for a dependable kicker for years. It’s been a constant blip on Joe Schoen’s radar.

It should not have mattered, though, especially after the Giants took a 21-17 lead. After stopping a fourth-down conversion at their own 31-yard line, the Giants needed 51 seconds to score. On the third play of the drive, McCarthy found Isaiah Likely on a dig route between two defenders at the 50, and he jetted to the end zone.

Washington tried to respond, but on the eighth play of their next drive, Jayden Daniels threw his first interception of the season. Jevón Holland, who registered his fourth pick, read a deep pass and beat Chigoziem Okonkwo at the goal line. The Giants got the ball back, up by four, with less than six minutes remaining.

With the ball at his team’s two-yard line, Cam Skattebo, who totaled 18 carries for 78 yards and two touchdowns, ran the ball twice for nine yards. On third-and-one, Harbaugh brought in Jameis Winston for a quarterback sneak. He thought he had reached the sticks, but replay review revealed he was short.

“Just got to get it,” Winston said. “Don’t even give them a chance to make a decision on it. I’ve done it before. Just flush it and move on.”

The Giants pretended to go for it on fourth down, and Winston tried to draw the Commanders offside by chanting “Who Let the Dogs Out.” It was strange, to say the least, but not odd enough to draw the Commanders offside. Washington got another shot with three minutes left.

Yet, somehow, the Giants intercepted Daniels again. This time, Ar’Darius Washington beat Okonkwo to a short pass, giving his team the ball at Washington’s 46-yard line with 2:15 remaining. That’s where trouble ensued, though. Skattebo rushed up the middle and to the left before McCarthy lost two yards on third down.

The Giants could have bought more time. They didn’t need to restrict themselves to running, which has been a struggle all season. Their 112.6 rushing yards per game rank 18th in the NFL. The Miami Dolphins and Los Angeles Chargers run the ball better.

“That’s something I’ve always prided myself on, playing on offense, being able to ice the game,” said fullback Patrick Ricard, whom the Giants acquired to create more lanes for Skattebo. “I feel like this year, we haven’t been able to do it. Only Week 1 did we actually run the ball and got first downs and were able to kneel the game out.”

The Commanders had the ball at their own 29-yard line with 1:46 left, and the clock expired on the Giants’ defense. First, Washington advanced 33 yards on a pass interference penalty to Deonte Banks. Three plays later, Daniels threw the ball out of the blitz to a streaking Stephon Diggs, who dodged two defenders for an uncontested touchdown.

But the Giants still had a chance. They almost lost it when Greg Desrosiers Jr. fumbled the kick return, but Chandler Martin recovered. Next, McCarthy, who finished 23-for-36 for a career-high 293 passing yards, completed a nifty pass to Malachi Fields before the Giants called their first timeout.

After two incompletions, McCarthy fired downfield to Nabers, double-teamed, and he couldn’t rotate in time to avoid the interception. Despite denouncing Greg Olsen’s comments last week that his body language sometimes suggests he can be a bad teammate, Nabers was nowhere to be found after the game.

He claimed he had to leave early because of a family emergency, and when he returned to MetLife Stadium, everybody had gone home. Unfortunately, that story is difficult to believe. Nabers, who always wears his emotions on his sleeve, was visibly demoralized after the game-ending interception.

Nabers’s reaction represented how every Giants fan felt in that moment. However, as Harbaugh said, “It’s disappointing, but you can’t let it bring you down. Our spirit is going to be fine. We’re not going to curl up. We’re not going to stop fighting. It’s going to be a long weekend.

The Giants, 5-3-1, have eight games left. They are 1-0 against Dallas and Philadelphia, but 0-1-1 against Washington, so they don’t own the tiebreaker. In second place, the Cowboys are 4-6, and in third, the Commanders are 3-5-1. The NFC East winner will host a Wild Card game.

“This was the one that got away,” Harbaugh reminisced. “It would have been nice to open up the lead in the division. We didn’t open it up as much as we could have if we’d won.”


The 5-3-1 Giants’ next game will be at home against the 7-2 Jacksonville Jaguars on Sunday, November 22, at 4:25 PM (3:25 PM CST) (CBS, Paramount+).

Cover Image Courtesy: New York Giants

Next
Next

Daily Report – 11/13/26